Robbing the Rich to Give to the Poor Essay - 917 Words

Robbing the Rich to Give to the Poor Poverty has conquered nations around the world, striking the populations down through disease and starvation. Small children with sunken eyes are displayed on national television to remind those sitting in warm, luxiourious houses that living conditions are less than tolerable around the world. Though it is easy to empathize for the poor, it is sometimes harder to reach into our pocketbooks and support them. No one desires people to suffer, but do wealthy nations have a moral obligation to aid poor nations who are unable to help themselves? Garrett Hardin in, Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor, uses a lifeboat analogy to expose the global negative consequences that could†¦show more content†¦Hardin attacks financial support to poor nations as he metaphorically compares it to the lifeboat scenerio in which the best situation is one in which no people are saved from the water thereby providing a better living condition for those already positioned in the b oat. Singer acknowledges Hardins arguments of property rights and population growth, yet combats the ethics of triage and suggests that one has a moral obligation of preventing some absolute poverty. Singer points out that absolute poverty is bad and it is within ones power to prevent some absolute power without sacrificing anything of comparable significance. Each author critiques whether one can have a moral obligation considering the impact of helping others out, yet in each position, global issues that encompass not one wealthy nation but all nations are coming into play. Religious and political views support Singer in his position that people ought to help out the poor. Singer proposes three premises that lead to the conclusion that one has a moral obligation to help out the poor. The first premise encourages one to sacrifice in order to aid another, if the sacrifice is appropriate. The second premise concludes that absolute poverty is a negative situation. The third pre mise that then leads to the conclusion that one should prevent some absolute poverty points out that it is within our power to prevent some absolute poverty. Singer is not alone in this view. In 1949,Show MoreRelatedAnalysis of Robin Hood Case1173 Words   |  5 Pageslieutenants as top management level, and see other people as employees, we can find that there is lack of middle management level in this organization. Under this circumstance, to decentralize the power means to build several functional departments and give each department right as well as responsibility of managing the organization. So the three top managers who are under supervision of CEO only needs to manage leaders of different departments and each leader will supervise their own departments; atRead MoreAnalysis Of The Movie Pancho Villa 1090 Words   |  5 Pagesjust for the land. But, for a revolution to happen, there has to be leaders, the leader that led the Mexican revolutionists was Doroteo Arrange, als o known as â€Å"Pancho Villa†. He was known for the Robin Hood for Mexico, would steal from the rich and give to the poor. He didn’t choose the life of a criminal; his destiny was to fight for justice in his country. Although Pancho Villa was a run away criminal, he was an important role in leading the revolution for the rebels. During the time that PorfidioRead MoreOutsiders Reflection on Difference783 Words   |  3 Pagesyouths of a town in Oklahoma, there is war. The two social classes, Greasers (the poor) and Socs (the rich), fight against one another, controlled by stereotypes, and two young teenagers change the history of it in a single night. The scene included in the movie when Dally robs the store gives the audience the understanding of how depressed and upset Dally Winston (Played by Matt Dillon) was and why he was led to robbing this store. This happened in the book, yes, but it never showed what really happenedRead MoreAmerica s Trade Area Of The Americas1494 Words   |  6 Pagesto try to save society. However, the only thing that it’s doing is hurting the social order. This happens because it creates more problems that are not being treated from the beginning. Crime has become a big problem during these hard times with the poor economy, but it has especially affected Latin America very deeply because of all the problems that overcrowded prisons have brought forward. In Latin America Brazil and Mexico are the two largest and strongest countries that have been affected withRead MoreRobin Hood: A Thief or a Hero? Essay840 Words   |  4 Pagesarcher. Robin Hood was a hero in his time. While many believe he w as a thief and a villain to the law, others feel he was a hero to the poor. Some people might say that Robin Hood stole from the government, and stealing is a crime, no matter what your cause is. They might also say that if people in this day and time stole from the rich and gave the money to the poor, they would be arrested because stealing is against the law. Finally, people who think Robin Hood was wrong in what he did might say thatRead MoreComparison of Journal of the Plague Year and Oroonoko Essay1147 Words   |  5 Pagestreatment of Africans was acceptable because they were a different species, and no amount of education or beauty could save them. Behn shows how unjust and brutal slavery is in Oroonoko. The treatment of slaves is comparable to the treatment of the poor, as both have few rights, and both are unjustly judged and mistreated based on social status. Behn begins Oroonoko with a description of the native people: they have long black hair, wear jewelry and paint flowers on their faces, and have allRead MoreThe French Revolution Was Inspired By The Ideas From The Enlightenment928 Words   |  4 Pagesagainst the normal traditions and religious beliefs relates to French Utopian Socialism because it challenges the normal British individualism by stating that the rich and poor should be more equal. French Utopian Socialism was seen as something that was too large to be realistic and did not succeed in its goal to equalize the poor and rich. Yet unsuccessful, the Voltaire s rebellious religious acts could have led French Revolutionists to want to create reforms on equality also. Cesare BeccariaRead MoreThe Failure Of The Insurrectionary Movement856 Words   |  4 Pagesare suffering in many ways in the hands of foreigners. The capitalist regime is taking everything from the natives and suffer huge monetary loss due to the high taxes. The natives cry foul of intruders who have taken control of everything including robbing the exchequer and carrying their proceeds to their home countries. Imperialism is the main argument that the author tries to bring out in this case. The foreigners exploited Canada’s natural resources at the expense of the local citizens. Local citizensRead MoreU.s. Presidential Election On The United States1042 Words   |  5 Pageswelfare policy are the most significant. Feizi stated in his teachings, â€Å"now if the ruler levies money from the rich in order to give alms to the poor, he is robbing the diligent and frugal and indulging the lazy and extravagant. If he expects by such a means to induce the people to work industriou sly and spend with caution, he will be disappointed.† The idea that providing for the poor by taxing the wealthy will discourage hard work is something that Trump believes, too. He wrote in his book TimeRead MoreMovie Analysis : The City And Suburb 1785 Words   |  8 Pagescontinual drenching rainfall making for o feeling of dystopic and scum. â€Å"How literary and film scholars observe a directors approach to visualizing and feelings towards the cities of their films. How the city should be perceived and the feelings it gives off. Movies can tell us much about our urban pasts present and future and provide insights into our collective hopes, fears, fantasies, and phobias.† As stated in the article Decent People Should Not Live Here. This can all also be seen in the movie